A company that keeps the design, controls production and outsources all processing may be classified as a manufacturer. This article sets out the three conditions for this model, the basis for the manufacturer's right to sell its own products and how to explain the model when registering the investment project.

About this article

Factoryless production is a model in which a company keeps the design, controls production and has another factory carry out all processing.

The content is for general information and does not replace legal advice on a specific case.

Assume an Italian designer sets up a company in Ho Chi Minh City to sell clothing under its own brand. The company designs the pieces, chooses the fabrics and hires a Vietnamese garment factory to make them. Most of the finished goods are exported, and part of them are sold on the company's website to customers in Vietnam. The company owns no sewing machines. The owner asks: "Is my company a manufacturer or a trader?"

If it is classified as a manufacturer, a foreign-invested company may sell the products it makes under the manufacturer's right to sell its own products, including by export, wholesale and retail through permitted channels. It then does not need a Business Licence or a Retail Outlet Licence to sell those products.

If it is classified as a trader, meaning that it only buys finished goods to resell, the company needs the export right and a distribution right, and a Business Licence when it sells at retail.

Classifying the business correctly is not only a matter of legal compliance. It also affects the company's actual scope of business and its commercial opportunities. A company whose activity is classified as trading often spends a great deal of time and money obtaining a Business Licence and Retail Outlet Licences.

In principle, a company that owns the design, controls production and has another factory carry out all processing may be classified as a manufacturer under Vietnam's business line classification. Nike is a familiar example of this model. According to the annual report Nike files with the United States Securities and Exchange Commission, Nike designs and develops its products and owns its brands, while independent contract manufacturers make the finished goods, including factories in Vietnam.

Even so, when a company relies on the factoryless production model, several important points need to be clarified, and explaining the model when registering the investment project also presents real challenges.

1. What a company must clarify when it relies on the factoryless production model

1.1. The company must meet all three conditions to be classified as a manufacturer

Under Vietnam's current business line classification, manufacturing includes factoryless goods producers. A company is classified in manufacturing when it meets all three conditions:

  • the company outsources the entire processing;
  • the company still controls the production process, from samples and materials to quality checks;
  • the company provides the key intellectual property inputs, such as the design and technical specifications.

Whether the company owns the raw materials does not change this result. The classification also places producing and selling goods in manufacturing, not in retail trade. The company in the hypothetical case therefore remains a manufacturer when it sells its own products.

1.2. Factoryless production differs from traditional processing and from pure trading

Under the Commercial Law, the processor carries out one or more production stages at the ordering party's request, for a fee. The ordering party may supply the materials, or the processor may supply part or all of them by agreement. A processing contract can therefore still be used when the factory buys the fabric itself to the company's specifications.

ModelWho owns the raw materialsWho owns the designSuitable business line code for the companyRight under which an FDI company sells
Traditional processing: the company supplies materials and samples to the factoryThe ordering companyThe ordering companyManufacturing, by product, for example code 1410 (manufacture of wearing apparel), if the company controls the production processThe manufacturer's right to sell its own products, in Vietnam and for export; no export right or distribution right needed
Factoryless production: the factory buys materials to the company's specificationsThe factoryThe ordering companyManufacturing, by product, for example 1410As in the row above
Pure trading: the company buys finished goods to resellThe manufacturerThe manufacturerWholesale and retail, by type of goods, for example code 4641 (wholesale of clothing) and code 4771 (retail sale of clothing)Export right, wholesale and retail distribution rights; Business Licence for retail

A company that outsources everything but does not control production, provides no key intellectual property inputs and does not own the raw materials is treated as buying finished goods for resale. It falls in the pure trading row.

1.3. A manufacturer sells under its right to sell its own products

Under Decree 342/2026/ND-CP, goods trading by a foreign-invested company consists of exercising the export right, the import right and the distribution right. A manufacturer selling its own products is not exercising any of these rights.

The Ministry of Industry and Trade has given guidance along these lines in a reply to a foreign-invested fashion company. Under the guidance, the wholesale and retail sale in Vietnam of goods that a foreign-invested company produces under its registered objectives and investment project is the exercise of its right to sell the goods it produces. This activity falls outside the rules on goods trading by foreign-invested companies.

The guidance was issued before Decree 342, and Decree 342 contains no different rule on a manufacturer selling its own products. In our view, the company in the hypothetical case may sell the products it has had made under this right. The right has three limits:

  • The right covers only the company's own products. Goods bought from others to sell alongside, such as accessories, are a trading activity. The company needs a distribution right or the export right for those goods, and a Business Licence if it sells them at retail.
  • Goods subject to business conditions must still meet those conditions. Both the Ministry's guidance and Decree 342 require the company to meet the business conditions set by law.
  • Physical stores and stores on e-commerce marketplaces have no specific guidance under Decree 342. In our view, as a matter of principle, a manufacturer selling its own products through a store or a marketplace store still exercises its right to sell its own products. Before opening a store or a marketplace store, the company should consult the local licensing authority.

1.4. The company should explain the outsourcing model in its investment registration file

The project proposal must state the project location and, where applicable, a preliminary environmental impact assessment. In factoryless production, the company's head office is often only an office. In our view, the investment registration authority may ask the company to explain where production takes place.

The project proposal should therefore describe the outsourcing model clearly: the company has a factory carry out all processing, does not manufacture at its head office, and keeps the design and quality control itself.

The company also needs to register the expected production capacity, for example the number of products per year. As a matter of principle, the investment registration authority will also review the project's investment capital closely to make sure it fits the business model.

2. A company registers business lines that match its actual activities

The registered business lines should reflect the activities the company actually carries out. In our view, the company should apply the following principles:

  • A manufacturer registers the manufacturing line that matches its products, not trading activities such as wholesale or retail, to sell its own products. Selling these products already falls within the manufacturer's right to sell its own products. If the company registers only wholesale and retail, it is treated as a trader, and it must obtain distribution rights and a Business Licence for retail.
  • The company registers wholesale or retail only when it buys goods from others to resell. For those goods, a foreign-invested company needs distribution rights, the export right if it exports, and a Business Licence for retail.
  • The company does not need a separate business line for each sales channel. Retail is classified by the goods sold, not by the sales channel. Once the company has registered retail sale of a product, it may sell that product by mail order or via the internet.
  • A company that connects buyers and sellers for a fee or commission registers an intermediary service. In that case, the company does not supply or own the goods sold. A company that sells its own goods does not register this line. In our view, a foreign-invested company providing intermediary services for goods needs a Business Licence.

3. The processing contract should settle five groups of terms

  • Ownership of designs, samples and moulds. The contract should state that designs, samples, patterns and moulds belong to the ordering company and must be returned when the contract ends. The ordering party is responsible for the lawfulness of the intellectual property rights in the goods and materials it hands to the processor.
  • Confidentiality. The contract should prohibit the factory from using the designs to produce for others.
  • Quality control. The ordering party may send staff to inspect and supervise the processing at the factory as agreed in the contract. The contract should set the standards, the acceptance procedure and the liability for goods that fail.
  • Labelling and origin. The contract should set the information on the label and which party prepares the documents proving origin for the importing market.
  • Delivery for export. The contract should state which party is named on the export declaration, and the place and time of delivery.

4. Conclusion

A company that keeps the design, controls production and has another factory carry out all processing may be classified as a manufacturer even without a factory. A foreign-invested company in that position sells its products under the manufacturer's right to sell its own products, and does not need distribution rights or a Business Licence for those products.

To be recognised as a manufacturer, the company needs to meet the three conditions of the factoryless production model, register the matching manufacturing line and explain the outsourcing model clearly in its project file. The processing contract should also show that the company keeps the design and controls quality. Goods bought from others for resale remain a trading activity and need the corresponding distribution rights and licences.

Tin & Partners can review the business model, the list of business lines and the project file with the company before filing.

Read on: goods trading by FDI enterprises