The article helps marketing teams check advertising campaigns, emails and cookies before launch.

About this article

An enterprise that uses personal data for advertising must have the customer's consent and must give the customer a way to refuse advertising. Online behaviour tracking data is sensitive data. The law prohibits buying and selling personal data. An enterprise that buys or sells personal data unlawfully may be fined up to 10 times the revenue obtained.

The content is for general information and does not replace legal advice on a specific case.

1. Marketing is subject to four sets of rules at once

A marketing campaign that uses customer data usually has to meet four sets of rules at once:

  • The general rules on consent: consent for each purpose, no default consent, silence is not consent, and evidence must be kept, as discussed in Valid consent on websites, apps, calls and paper.
  • The specific rules on advertising using personal data, including behavioural, targeted and personalised advertising.
  • The prohibition on buying and selling personal data, unless a law provides otherwise.
  • The rules against spam text messages, spam emails and spam calls, together with advertising law.

Data that tracks a person's behaviour and use of services in cyberspace is sensitive data, as discussed in Sensitive personal data and children's data. When seeking consent to track behaviour for advertising, the enterprise must therefore tell customers that this is sensitive data. The enterprise must also apply specific security measures and access controls to this data.

An enterprise may process customer data for advertising only with the customer's consent. Before consenting, the customer must clearly know the content, method, form and frequency of the product promotion. The enterprise must provide a way for customers to refuse advertising and must stop advertising when a customer asks.

In practice, the enterprise should ensure that:

  • The box for consent to marketing is separate from acceptance of the terms of service and is not pre-ticked.
  • The consent wording states the channels, such as text messages, emails, calls or in-app notifications, and the expected frequency.
  • Every marketing text or email has a simple way to refuse. When a customer refuses, the enterprise stops marketing on all channels.
  • Customers who do not consent to marketing still receive the main service.

When using personal data for behavioural, targeted or personalised advertising, the enterprise must meet three further requirements:

  • The enterprise may collect data by tracking on websites, portals or applications only with the data subject's consent.
  • The enterprise must give the data subject a way to refuse data sharing.
  • The enterprise must set a retention period, and delete or destroy the data when it is no longer needed.

Providers of social networks and online communication services have two further duties:

  • The provider must let users refuse the collection and sharing of cookies.
  • The provider must offer a "do not track" option, or track only with the user's consent.

Vietnamese law does not yet classify cookies as European law does. In Europe, an enterprise does not need consent for cookies strictly necessary to run a website. An enterprise running a commercial website should separate two groups: cookies that serve the site's functions, and cookies and tracking pixels used for advertising. The enterprise should activate the second group only after the user consents.

4. Buying and selling personal data is prohibited, even when called sharing or partnership

Buying and selling personal data is prohibited, unless a law provides otherwise. A transfer of data for a fee is not treated as a sale when it falls within the permitted cases, such as a transfer with the data subject's consent, or a transfer to a processor under contract. For a fee-based transfer based on consent, the enterprise must also meet these conditions:

  • Have a technical system that lets the data subject consent to each transfer and know the exact purpose and recipient.
  • Ensure that the recipient processes the data only for the purpose consented to and consistently with its registered business lines.
  • Limit the types of data transferred to the purpose.
  • Not build a data pool for other purposes.
  • Sign a transfer agreement before the transfer, defining the roles of the parties.

Outside these cases, if an enterprise provides, shares or exchanges data for money or other benefits, this is treated as unlawful buying and selling. Two enterprises that swap customer lists also fall within this category, even with no money paid, because each gains a benefit. Personal data must be de-identified before it is traded on a data exchange.

The fine for unlawful buying and selling of data is 2 to 10 times the revenue obtained. Revenue means the total transaction value shown on contracts, invoices, payment documents, messages or statements, without deducting any costs. If no revenue can be identified, the fine depends on the number of data subjects. The fine ranges from VND 70 million where there are fewer than 1,000 data subjects to VND 1 billion where there are 10,000 or more. Where serious harm results, the fine may reach VND 3 billion.

Besides the fine, the enterprise must delete the data traded from all systems. It may also be required to notify everyone affected.

5. Advertising service businesses have their own duties

An advertising service business may use only two kinds of customer data: data transferred by the controller under an agreement; and data the business collects through its own operations. It must:

  • Prove that its use of customer data for advertising is lawful.
  • Provide a mechanism for the data subject to refuse, and stop advertising when the data subject asks.
  • Not subcontract or arrange for another party to perform, on its behalf, the entire advertising service using personal data. It may outsource part of the work, but may not simply sign the contract and have another party perform the whole service.

The enterprise engaging the service also has responsibilities. Because the enterprise is the controller, it may transfer data to an advertising business only as permitted by law. The transfer must have a legal basis, be made under an agreement and serve the purpose the customers consented to.

6. Marketing texts, emails and calls have their own rules

The rules against spam texts, spam emails and spam calls apply in parallel with personal data rules. The main requirements for advertisers are:

  • Send marketing texts and emails and make marketing calls only when the recipient has clearly consented.
  • Label marketing texts and emails correctly and use an assigned brand name.
  • Send no more than 3 texts, no more than 3 emails and no more than 1 marketing call to a person within 24 hours, unless agreed otherwise.
  • Send marketing texts only between 07:00 and 22:00 and make marketing calls only between 08:00 and 17:00, unless agreed otherwise.
  • Do not text or call numbers on the Do Not Call List.
  • Stop sending immediately after the recipient refuses.
  • Keep records of marketing sign-ups and refusals for at least 1 year.

These breaches are sanctioned under the cybersecurity group of offences. The fine for an organisation is twice the fine for an individual. For example, an organisation that sends marketing texts without consent may be fined VND 20 million to 40 million. An organisation that sends them to numbers on the Do Not Call List may be fined VND 160 million to 180 million.

7. Four cases and the conclusions

7.1. An e-commerce site loads advertising trackers before the user chooses

An online shop installs an advertising network's tracking code and activates it as soon as a visitor opens the page. The cookie banner has only an "Accept" button. The enterprise collects behaviour tracking data, which is sensitive data, for advertising without consent. The fine for this breach is VND 50 million to 70 million. The enterprise should block the tracking code until the user consents, and offer a refuse button as prominent as the accept button.

7.2. A retail chain lets an insurance partner use its loyalty customer list

A retail chain receives a referral fee for letting an insurance partner call its loyalty customers. The customers consented only to receive the chain's own offers. This is a fee-based transfer outside the scope of the customers' consent, so it is treated as an unlawful sale. The fine is 2 to 10 times the referral fees received. For the transfer to be lawful, the chain must obtain the customers' separate consent for each transfer of data to the named partner.

7.3. An enterprise buys a list of phone numbers for sales calls

A real estate company buys a list of 20,000 phone numbers with names for telemarketing. Both the seller and the buyer breach the prohibition on buying and selling data. Calls to people who have not consented also breach the rules on spam calls. Where the transaction brings illegal gains or causes damage at the levels set by law, the persons involved may face criminal liability.

7.4. A food delivery app personalises offers based on order history

An app uses order history to send offers suited to each user. This is personalised advertising. The app needs to do three things: obtain separate consent for this purpose; let users turn off personalisation in the settings; set a retention period for behavioural data. Users who have turned off personalisation must still be able to order as usual.

IssueVietnamEuropean Union
CookiesTracking for advertising requires consent; social network providers must let users refuse cookies and choose "do not track"All non-essential cookies require prior consent; strictly necessary cookies are exempt
Online behaviour dataSensitive dataOrdinary personal data, unless it reveals special category information
Direct marketingRequires consent and a way to refuseMay rely on legitimate interests in some cases; the right to object is absolute
Sale of dataProhibited, unless a law provides otherwiseNot specifically prohibited, but requires a legal basis and transparency

In 2022 the French data protection authority (CNIL) announced fines totalling EUR 150 million against Google and EUR 60 million against Facebook. The reason was that users in France could accept cookies with one click but needed several steps to refuse them. Vietnamese law prohibits enterprises from giving unclear or misleading instructions between consent and refusal. The law does not say expressly that refusing must be as easy as accepting. In our assessment, this rule requires the option to refuse to be as clear and visible as the option to accept.

9. What to avoid when using personal data in marketing

  • Bundling marketing consent into the terms of service, so customers cannot refuse it separately.
  • Activating trackers before the user chooses, or offering only an "Accept" button.
  • Treating the sharing of customer lists with partners as a business partnership, when in substance it is a transfer of data for gain.
  • Buying data from third parties without checking its origin and consent.
  • Applying a refusal on one channel while continuing to send marketing through another.

10. What enterprises should do

  • List the cookies and tracking codes on the website and app. Block the cookies and tracking codes used for advertising until the user consents.
  • Separate marketing consent by channel and state the frequency. Keep evidence of consents and refusals.
  • Maintain a single suppression list for all channels and for every agency sending marketing on the enterprise's behalf.
  • Review every arrangement that transfers customer data to partners, especially those involving referral fees or revenue sharing.
  • Sign data processing agreements with advertising agencies, which prohibit them from subcontracting the whole service and require them to check against the Do Not Call List.
  • Check the sending schedule for texts and calls against the volume limits and time windows.

Read on in the Personal data protection series