An FDI company may play a different role for each of its personal data flows. The hypothetical case in this article helps the company build a role table for its own data flows.

About this article

In personal data protection, an enterprise usually has more than one role. The same company may be a controller and processor for one data flow, and a controller for another. In the remaining flows, it hands data to a processor, an independent controller or a third party. This article illustrates the point with a hypothetical case of five data flows.

The content is for general information and does not replace legal advice on a specific case.

1. Hypothetical case: a foreign invested company with five data flows

Company A (hypothetical) is a foreign invested limited liability company that manufactures and sells household goods in Vietnam. It has about 400 employees, a factory, a showroom and an online shop. Its parent company is based abroad.

Company A has five main data flows:

  1. Recruitment.
  2. Online sales.
  3. Security cameras at the factory and showroom.
  4. The group's shared HR software.
  5. Advertising through an advertising agency.

For each flow, the article answers three questions: who is involved, what role each party plays, and what Company A's main obligations are. Section 7 sets out once the general obligations that apply to every flow, such as the impact assessment dossier, the appointment of data protection staff and breach notification within 72 hours.

2. Recruitment: Company A is the controller and processor

Company A advertises vacancies on its own website, receives applications by email and conducts interviews itself. For management positions, it engages a headhunting firm to introduce candidates.

PartyRoleMain obligations
Company AController and processorRequest only information needed for recruitment; obtain the candidate's consent; delete records of unsuccessful candidates unless otherwise agreed
Headhunting firmIndependent controller for its own candidate databaseEnsure the candidate has consented before introducing the profile to Company A
CandidatesData subjectsProvide accurate information; may withdraw consent and ask for deletion

Points to note. The headhunting firm builds and uses its own candidate database for many clients. It is therefore not Company A's processor. When receiving profiles from the firm, Company A should ask for a commitment that candidates have agreed to be introduced.

If Company A wants to keep unsuccessful candidates' files for future rounds, it needs a separate agreement with the candidate stating the retention period. Health status is sensitive data. Company A should collect it only where it is genuinely needed for the position.

3. Online sales: Company A is the controller with several data recipients

Company A's online shop runs on rented software from a technology company. Buyers pay through a payment intermediary and receive goods through a delivery company.

PartyRoleMain obligations
Company AControllerState purposes clearly; separate marketing consent from the purchase; no pre-ticked boxes; keep evidence of consent
E-commerce platform providerProcessorProcess only under the contract; apply security measures; report incidents to Company A
Payment intermediaryIndependent controller for payment dataComply with data protection rules for finance and banking
Delivery companyProcessor, or independent controller if it uses the data for its own purposesUse the address and phone number only for delivery unless the contract allows otherwise
BuyersData subjectsConsent or refuse for each purpose

Points to note. When it delivers goods, Company A performs the sale agreement with the buyer. It therefore needs no separate consent for that purpose. By contrast, Company A needs separate consent to send promotional messages.

Bank card information is sensitive data. If the shop redirects buyers to the payment gateway and Company A does not store card numbers, Company A significantly reduces its risk relating to card data. In our assessment, the payment intermediary is an independent controller, because it processes payment data under its own duties in the payments sector. Company A should also check whether the platform provider's service falls within the list of personal data processing services that require a certificate.

4. Cameras: Company A is the controller and processor, the security firm is a processor

Company A installs cameras at the factory gate, on the production floor and in the showroom. A security services firm watches the screens and extracts footage when Company A asks. Footage is stored on a recorder at the factory.

PartyRoleMain obligations
Company AController and processorInform employees and visitors of recording; limit retention; restrict who may view and extract footage
Security services firmProcessorView and extract footage only at Company A's request; do not copy or share it
Employees, visitors, couriersData subjectsEntitled to know they are being recorded
Police, when an incident occursThird partyReceive footage at the request of a competent authority

Points to note. For employees, the law allows technological management measures only where employees are clearly aware of them. The internal labour rules and signs at camera locations are suitable ways to inform them.

The showroom is open to customers. Recording there may therefore fall under the rules on recording in public places. Even so, Company A must still inform visitors that they are being recorded. Company A must not place cameras in changing rooms or toilets.

If the cameras use facial recognition, the data collected is biometric data. This is sensitive data. Company A must therefore meet stricter security requirements.

5. Group HR software: the parent is a processor or a controller depending on the purpose

The group requires Company A to use a shared HR system hosted on a cloud service with servers abroad. The parent company administers the system. It holds personnel files, payroll, performance reviews and succession plans. The parent's regional HR team uses review data to decide regional promotions.

PartyRoleMain obligations
Company AController for its own employee dataInform employees of the transfer abroad; consider the duty to prepare a cross-border transfer impact assessment dossier; sign an agreement with the parent
Parent company, when operating the systemProcessorProcess only under the agreement with Company A; keep data secure; report incidents
Parent company, when deciding regional promotionsIndependent controllerA transfer agreement stating the purpose, types of data and period
Cloud service providerProcessor, usually of the parent companyEncrypt data at rest and in transit; meet the specific requirements for cloud contracts

Points to note. Storing data on servers abroad is a cross-border transfer of personal data. The law exempts certain cases from the cross-border transfer impact assessment dossier. Two of them concern Company A:

  • An organisation storing its own employees' data on a cloud service.
  • An organisation transferring data for cross-border personnel management under labour regulations and collective labour agreements.

Company A needs to check whether its actual data flow falls entirely within these exemptions. If the parent also uses the data for other purposes, such as group analytics beyond personnel management, that part of the transfer may not be exempt.

If the system holds fingerprint or face attendance data, that data is sensitive. When transferring this data, Company A needs stronger security measures.

6. Advertising: the agency has its own duties under the law

Company A engages an advertising agency to run social media campaigns. The agency proposes two things:

  • The agency uploads customers' phone numbers and email addresses to the advertising platform to find similar audiences.
  • The agency places tracking code on the online shop to retarget people who viewed products.
PartyRoleMain obligations
Company AControllerTransfer data to the agency only as the law permits; obtain customers' consent for advertising; obtain consent before activating tracking code
Advertising agencyProcessor for the data transferred by Company A, and also an advertising service business with its own dutiesUse only data transferred under the agreement; be able to prove its use of the data; stop advertising when a customer asks; not subcontract the entire service to another party
Overseas advertising platformController for its own processingUnder the platform's terms; uploading data to it is a cross-border transfer
CustomersData subjectsMay refuse advertising at any time

Points to note. In our assessment, this is the riskiest of the five flows. Data from tracking a person's behaviour online is sensitive data. Company A may collect data by tracking websites or apps for behavioural advertising only with the customer's consent. A customer who agreed to receive promotional emails has not necessarily agreed to Company A uploading their details to an advertising platform. Company A must obtain consent for each purpose.

7. Obligations that apply across all five flows

  • A personal data processing impact assessment dossier: Company A prepares one dossier describing all five flows and the parties involved, and files it with the specialised authority within 60 days of the first processing.
  • A cross-border transfer impact assessment dossier: Company A considers whether it must prepare one for the HR software flow and the advertising flow.
  • Data protection staff or a data protection unit: Company A must appoint a qualified unit or staff member, or engage an organisation or individual providing personal data protection services. The law relaxes this duty only for household businesses and micro, small and start-up enterprises. Household businesses and micro enterprises are not required to meet it. Small enterprises and startups may choose whether to meet it for 5 years from 1 January 2026. Under the classification criteria, small and medium enterprises have an annual average of no more than 200 employees on social insurance. Company A has 400 employees on social insurance, so it falls into none of these groups.
  • A single procedure for data subject requests: Company A uses one procedure for customers, employees and candidates, ensuring a response within 2 working days.
  • A procedure for breach notification within 72 hours: Company A sets up this procedure. The contract with each processor states its incident reporting duty.

8. What to avoid in data mapping

  • Recording a single role for the whole enterprise. Company A has at least three different roles across the five flows.
  • Treating the use of group software as an internal matter. The parent is a separate legal entity abroad, so the transfer needs its own agreement and assessment.
  • Letting the agency place tracking code without Company A controlling how consent is obtained.
  • Installing cameras first and informing staff later. Employees must be clearly aware of a monitoring measure before it is applied.

9. What enterprises should do

  • Map data flow by flow, with three columns: party, role, main obligations.
  • Compare the map with existing contracts and sign any missing processing or transfer agreements.
  • Separate consent boxes for purchases, promotional messages, behavioural advertising and uploads to advertising platforms.
  • Review data flows to the parent company and determine which parts are exempt from the cross-border transfer dossier and which are not.
  • Update the internal labour rules on cameras and other monitoring measures.
  • Set deletion deadlines for unsuccessful candidates' files and camera footage.

Read on in the Personal data protection series